Category Archives: Articles

Film Appreciation: My Left Foot

Film Appreciation: My Left Foot

“I saw it as more than a rather grim story of a man in a wheelchair. Christy represented for me a real kind of heroism, and I really wanted to try to capture the rage and frustration that led him to paint and write. To show, I suppose, that the trap is not the wheelchair or the afflictions, but our attitude to disabled people.”

Daniel Day-Lewis On His Role In My Left Foot,

To Arena Magazine, Summer-Autumn 1989

Jim Sheridan’s My Left Foot shows bleak real-life events, but the film itself is not depressing. This is partly due to the non-linear storytelling, which softens the more difficult aspects of the narrative. However, the larger share of credit goes to Daniel Day-Lewis and Brenda Fricker for their powerhouse performances as Irish writer/painter Christy Brown and his mother.

However, it is also true that Sheridan simply did not focus on certain aspects of Christy’s life. I will comment on those in a separate section.

The Film

The openings scenes show the adult Christy at a charity benefit. He is introduced to his nurse, Mary Carr, and hands her a copy of his autobiography, My Left Foot. She begins to read, which triggers a series of flashbacks.

Christy is born in 1932 and is diagnosed with severe cerebral palsy. Doctors recommend putting him into a hospital, but the Browns insist on keeping him at home. (A very effective Hugh O’Conor plays Christy when young.)

Mrs. Brown refuses to believe Christy cannot learn. She takes him with her everywhere in a wooden cart (the Browns cannot afford a wheelchair) and talks to him constantly. Mr. Brown is ashamed to have a handicapped child and avoids contact with Christy.

One day Christy astounds them all when he grabs a piece of chalk by his left foot, the only part of his body that he can manage to control. He writes “MOTHER” on the floor tiles. Even Mr. Brown is impressed.

From there, Christy progresses to painting. His brothers include him in their activities, even soccer. Christy meets Dr. Eileen Cole (Fiona Shaw), who encourages him to come to her school for cerebral palsy patients.

Dr. Cole supports his painting and even helps him to get an exhibition. Unfortunately, Christy mistakes her interest for love. He has trouble dealing with Dr. Cole’s engagement and considers suicide. Soon after, Mr. Brown dies of a stroke. Christy begins writing his autobiography.

Now we are back at the charity benefit. Christy asks Mary out, and she accepts. The film ends with a super telling us they later married.

What Is Not In The Film

After My Left Foot was published in 1954, Christy began corresponding with a married American named Beth Moore. He visited Moore at her Connecticut home in 1960; in 1965, they began an affair. Christy’s second novel, Down All The Days, was published in 1970 and bears the following dedication:

         For Beth, who with such gentle ferocity,

         Finally whipped me into finishing this book.

Christy ended the relationship when he began seeing Mary Carr, whom he appears to have met at a party. I could not able to find any evidence that she was his nurse. They married in 1972, as the film says. By most accounts, Christy’s health deteriorated after the marriage. He died in 1981 at age forty-nine, the result of choking at dinner.

The Young Christy Brown

 

Something To Bear In Mind

Besides the two novels mentioned, Christy published three additional novels and three volumes of poetry. (The 1991 Collected Poems Of Christy Brown is a posthumous compilation of his three books of poetry.) That is in addition to his paintings. All this from a guy who could only type with one foot.

I’m going to close with a section from one of Christy’s poems that conveys frustration but not defeat. They strike me as being emblematic of him. The poem is called “Lines Of Leaving”.

“Your gentleness disarmed me

wine in my desert

peace across impassable seas

path of light in my jungle

Now uncatchable as the wind you go

beyond the wind

and there is nothing in my world

save the straw of salvation in the amber dream.

The absurdity of that vast improbable joy.

The absurdity of you gone.”

 

Theme: Art Overcomes Adversity

Related Posts: Film Review: Maudie  http://www.thinkingcinema.com/film-review-maudie/

Art Overcomes Adversity: List For Week Ending June 25, 2017  http://www.thinkingcinema.com/art-overcomes-adversity-list-for-week-ending-june-25-2017/

Sources:

746 Books: https://746books.com/2015/03/21/world-poetry-day-christy-brown-background-music/

IMDb: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0097937/

TCM: http://www.tcm.com/this-month/article.html?isPreview=&id=218705|218342&name=My-Left-Foot

Wikipedia:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/My_Left_Foot

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christy_Brown

Film Appreciation: Letter To An Unknown Woman

Film Appreciation: Letter To An Unknown Woman

PLOT SPOILERS THROUGHOUT Letter From An Unknown Woman (1948) is worth seeing because it shows a group of talented individuals-Max Ophuls, Howard Koch, Franz Planer and Alexander Golitzen among them-at the top of their form. Honesty compels me to add that the story, adapted from the Stefan Zweig novel of the same name, requires considerableContinue Reading

Film Appreciation: Don’t Look Now

Film Appreciation: Don’t Look Now

“Nothing is what it seems.” John Baxter This line, spoken casually in the opening minutes of Don’t Look Now (1973), almost serve as a tip-off to the audience. Very little in Nicolas Roeg’s film can be taken at face value, or understood in isolation. John (Donald Sutherland) is a professional restorer of buildings. At theContinue Reading

Film Appreciation: Mother Of George

Film Appreciation: Mother Of George

Mother Of George is a visually stunning film with a complex story line. A couple finds their marriage under threat when the attitudes of modern New York clash with their Yoruban (Nigerian) traditions. Director Andrew Dosunmu, working from a script by Darci Picoult, provides ample clues as to why such tensions occur and why compromiseContinue Reading

Film Appreciation: Without Lying Down

Film Appreciation: Without Lying Down

“I’ve spent my life searching for a man I could look up to without lying down.” Frances Marion Bridget Terry’s captivating film is inspired by Cari Beauchamp’s book Without Lying Down: Frances Marion And The Power Of Women In Hollywood. This may sound like an ironic title to some; I assure you it is not.Continue Reading

Film Appreciation: Beginners

Film Appreciation: Beginners

Mike Mills’ second film, Beginners, has a title that describes its main characters. All are adults, but beginners when it comes to relationships. Beginners is a funny, rueful, and ultimately hopeful film about moving on after loss. It is the story of Oliver (Ewan McGregor) who has just lost his father, Hal (Christopher Plummer), toContinue Reading

Film Appreciation: Incendies

Film Appreciation: Incendies

Incendies (2010) is a spellbinding film that does not compromise. Writer/director Denis Villeneuve is vague about the story’s location. However, it seems fairly clear that events of the non-linear narrative occur in two places: modern-day Canada and Lebanon during its civil war (1975-1990). Incendies, which is based on a play of the same name, dealsContinue Reading

Film Appreciation: Dr. Zhivago

Film Appreciation: Dr. Zhivago

A bit of trivia-the first screen adaptation of Dr. Zhivago was a 1959 Brazilian television mini series called Doutor Jivago. It was also made as a mini series in 2002 and 2006. But if you ask someone to recall a screen version of Dr. Zhivago, chances are they will mention David Lean’s 1965 film. Dr.Continue Reading

Film Appreciation: Living In Oblivion

Film Appreciation: Living In Oblivion

You do not have to be fan of independent films to enjoy Living In Oblivion, but it helps. Tom DiCillo’s film is a warts-and-all depiction of shooting on a low-budget indie. It is real, and often savagely funny. DiCillo was experiencing a high level of professional frustration in 1993. Despite having won Best Picture atContinue Reading